Signal blocks AI assistants from reading chats, but admits the fix is incomplete
Signal says its screenshot block leaves gaps that AI agents can still use, and it wants Apple, Google and Microsoft to offer a standard opt-out.
Signal has begun blocking screenshots by default in its app on iOS 27 and on Android when an AI assistant tries to read the screen, aiming to keep built-in assistants such as Siri and Gemini from pulling chat content onto servers outside Signal's control. Users can switch the protection off in settings, but Signal warns that doing so could expose their own and their contacts' messages to those agents and undermine its privacy guarantees. The company concedes the measure is incomplete, since agents could still reach data through the device file system, notifications or accessibility permissions, and on macOS it has no protection at all. Signal is pressing Apple, Google and Microsoft for a standard, documented way for developers to opt out of AI data access, and it cites Reuters' report that Meta's Muse agent read Signal messages through broad device permissions.
Why it matters
The episode shows that a messaging app's privacy promises depend on what the operating system lets other software do. Signal can block screenshots, but it cannot fully stop agents that reach data through the file system or broad permissions, and on macOS it has no protection at all. For users, the practical question is which apps and assistants hold the permissions that would let them read private conversations, and whether platform makers will give apps a documented way to refuse that access.
Matters or hype?
Does this story matter, or is it hype? Vote before you see what everyone else said.