Trusence Every claim has a source
Last updated 21 November 2026 Search Türkçe
Policy

UK tribunal rules Home Office must acknowledge Apple encryption order

Apple's challenge and a related case from Privacy International and Liberty can now proceed largely in open court, though the legality of the demand is still undecided.

A UK tribunal has ruled that the Home Office must acknowledge it served Apple with a technical capability notice, an order that can require encrypted customer data to be made accessible to security services. The judges concluded that earlier media disclosures and talks with US officials had already undercut the government's neither-confirm-nor-deny stance, and they called the claim that confirmation would harm national security fanciful. As a result, much of Apple's challenge, along with a separate case from Privacy International and Liberty, can now proceed largely in open court, though the legality of the demand is still undecided. Apple's latest challenge was filed in July after a second notice replaced an earlier one that had covered UK and US users. The dispute already led Apple to stop offering Advanced Data Protection to new UK users in February 2025, and affected users have been told they will get a period to disable it, with no deadline yet set.

Why it matters

The ruling means the government can no longer keep the existence of the order secret, which opens the dispute to public scrutiny. For UK users, the practical effect so far is that Apple has stopped offering Advanced Data Protection to new British customers and existing users have been told they will get a period to disable it, with no deadline set. Whether the order itself is lawful remains unresolved and will be tested in the open proceedings ahead.

Sources · 1